Common App Music Supplement (Voice)

Hello, we had my son’s voice recorded for a possible music supplement. The question I have is should we submit this supplement to the colleges, or is it not of sufficient quality or, alternatively, does it not meet the requirements for submission? Here are links to the recordings:

https://vimeo.com/atcdanno/gia-il-sole-dal-gange
https://vimeo.com/atcdanno/where-ere-you-walk
https://vimeo.com/atcdanno/she-was-there

Thank you.

To me, the recordings do not reflect the level of skill where a voice supplement would be beneficial. He very well may be an extremely talented singer, but that doesn’t really come across in these particular videos.

I say submit it. Your son sounds great! And if nothing else, it certainly won’t hurt your application.

Thank you for your opinions. Even if they are contradictory. He still has a few weeks to decide. He is going to record two other songs this Sunday, and perhaps they will come across better than the first group.