My FIRST ever SAT ESSAY!! Grade, please. :)

<h2>PLEASE give comments/feedback for improvement! I am a new here, and new to the SAT too. But this is not an excuse.</h2>

<br>


<br>

<p>People make their own destinies; what we do, is what defines us. Identity, something we need to earn through effort and persistence, is not inherent. Though some people might be born in more privileged conditions than some others, those privileged conditions can help them only till a certain extent. Moreover, the world does not define you, for things you have not achieved, it defines you for the things that you have fought for. Many examples from literature and history can support this viewpoint.
Nelson Mandela, was born in a modest family, and didn't have an 'identity' of his own. In 1962 he was arrested and convicted of sabotage and other charges, and sentenced to life in prison. Mandela served 27 years in prison, spending many of these years on Robben Island. But when he came out, he had a smile on his face, and so sign of animosity or hostility; he in fact hugged and shook hands with very people who subjected him to a life, which some people might call, of misery. Mandela is known for his resilience, and his courage to forgive. He successfully ended the apartheid in South Africa, and all his earnest actions resulted in, he becoming the President of South Africa. As shown by the life of Mandela, it were his actions and his novel thoughts that appealed to the world, making him a global icon, and ultimately immortalizing his name in the sands of time.
Another fine example can be found in literature, in 'Kane and Abel' by Jeffrey Archer. Abel Rosnovski, a Polish immigrant comes to the United States of America, with a heart full of dreams, and a pocket full of nothing. He, along with all his Polish immigrant friends, joined a hotel to work as a waiter. He says to his friends that one day he'll become a millionaire through sheer hard work and perseverance. His friends laugh at him and his ludicrous words. Within years, he becomes a millionaire, owning a chain of hotels, including the one he served as a waiter. He 'chose' to be successful, and he did. He succeeded in creating an identity of his own.
As demonstrated by the life APJ Abdul Kalam, formed President of India, it is our vision and resilience that serve as a barometer for success. Kalam was born in an impoverished family, he father being a fisherman. But his economic conditions didn't stop him from becoming successful. Kalam played a pivotal organisational, technical and political role in India's Pokhran-II nuclear test in 1998, the first since the original nuclear test by India in 1974. And in 2002, he became the President of India; during his term as President, he was popularly known as the People's President. If identity was something he was borin with or given, he would not be considered today as one of India's greatest scientists, a benevolent leader, and a far-sighted visionary.<br>
To conclude, it is our actions and thoughts that determine who we are. Life gives us, many opportunities to prove our worth, and we a choice to maker. We can either sit back, bask in our glory (whatever this is), and succumb to failure, or we can get up, move out of our cosy rooms, and face the world armed with nothing but confidence and the zeal to achieve. The choice is ours.</p>

<p>BUMP.
Please grade and comment. :slight_smile:
Please…</p>

<p>25 people have viewed my essay, and none of you has HAS/HAVE (??) [I think, have] graded it. :|</p>

<p>this is weird. :/</p>

<p>6/12</p>

<p>Is English your second language? There are a lot of awkward grammatical mistakes. Also why, do you write, like this?</p>

<p>Yes, English is my second language. I am not from the US. Thanks for the honest review. Could you list my awkward grammatical mistakes, and the excessive use of punctuation? This will help me improve.</p>

<p>Good thing I posted the essay here. Stupid Collegeboard’s online scoring service gave me a 12. </p>

<p>Any more comments? Be specific.</p>

<p>I request everyone who reads this essay to grade it! Thanks a million. :slight_smile:
I will try my best to improve on my essay. I don’t want to end up getting a 6/12 on it, in the SAT.</p>

<p>How is this a 6/12 essay? I have read 6/12 essays, and they are brusque, short and full of circumlocutions. This essay seems like about 400 words and has good examples. I will go with 10.</p>

<p>^ thanks! Any comments?</p>

<p>Great examples and solid support. The only thing stopping this from being an 11 or a 12 are the disproportionate amount of commas. Fix the punctuation and you should have no trouble at all with the essay portion.</p>

<p>^Thank you! I’ll try my best! Thanks for the suggestion.
:)</p>

<p>Tell me my weakness too; after all, the purpose of posting this essay is here to get as much input from you guys… :)</p>

<p>Did you really have all of these very specific examples in your head?!?!?! Also, your comma use is VERY awkward.</p>

<p>All right, I’ll improve on the punctuation. Though I feel there aren’t many punctuation related errors. What about the score?
And thanks!</p>

<p>Specific examples? haha, look carefully. My examples are actually very general yet to the point. I have a few selected examples that I use for any topic. You just have to learn to mold them in such a way that they favor your stand. :)</p>

<p>Well the dates are pretty specific but I’ll trust you.
There are quite a few grammatical errors
ex.it were his actions
resulted in, he becoming the President of South Africa
, he father being a fisherman.</p>

<p>To name a few of many…
Also, you may “feel” that there are not many punctuation related errors, but there are many (in almost every sentence)</p>

<p>I am not qualified to grade but my guess would be about an 8 or so. Without the grammatical mistakes I would say a 10-11. The ideas and flow are clear.</p>

<p>The he/his mistakes or whatever, are just typos. I printed the test and took it, and then later on typed it here. Most of the grammatical awkward words/phrases are merely because of careless typing.
Anyway thanks!</p>

<p>Can anyone else please have a look at my essay? thanks in advance!!</p>

<p>^ thanks.
Any more comments?</p>

<p>^^ Whose essay is this? :)</p>

<p>I think this essay should score between an 8 and a 10. Not only is it rife with grammatical and spelling errors but it also lacks flow from one idea/example to the next.
The examples, too, are somewhat weak in supporting your main thesis.</p>

<p>The good news is that your writing style and wide vocabulary could easily net you a 12 provided you choose strong examples, avoid adding unnecessary commas and stick to a pre-determined structure.</p>

<p>Good luck!</p>

<p>^ Thanks a tonne! Can you tell me why my examples don’t strongly support my thesis, and which examples/changes would you recommend for a more cogent argument?</p>