Please Grade My Essay :)

<p>Been lurking on CC for quite a while now, here's my first post! I've been practicing my essays, and I'd like some opinions. The question below is actually from one of the practice tests in the Blue Book, answered under timed conditions. What do you think?</p>

<h2>Any criticism or help is greatly appreciated. Thanks! ^^</h2>

<p>ASSIGNMENT: Can success be disastrous?</p>

<p>ESSAY:
Most of us spend our lives pining for success, in the belief that we will finally find happiness and satisfaction upon its attainment. However, we fail to realise that success might instead have undesirable side-effects on encroach upon the lives of others, as can be seen from "Brave New World" and World War II, and hence be disastrous.</p>

<p>In Aldous Huxley's novel "Brave New World", the world government has seemingly achieved success in creating a utopia for all citizens. Society runs like clockwork, everyone is contented with his or her position in life and there are even "soma" pills that leave users bursting with happiness. Yet, as the novel progresses, it reveals some chilling aspects of society that leave us questioning whether such "success" was worth it. People are genetically engineered at birth to suit their roles in society, the government has become despotic with unlimited power over the automatons that citizens have become, and the world appears to be more of a dystopia than a utopia. The novel leaves us questioning if the success was worth its cost, and proves that success can indeed be disastrous.</p>

<p>We can also observe the double-edged sword of success from history. In World War II, the rising Japanese empire sought to assert its power by conquering neighbouring territories. That it did, with great success (at least in the words of the Japanese), invading China and capturing large tracts of lands. However, their military success costed them greatly in post-war relations. China today still harbours grudges towards Japan for the latter's ruthless invasions, and tensions between the countries have hit oiling point in recent years, following a resurgence of nationalistic sentiments. As a result, Japan's economic ties with China, a major importer, have taken a hit, affecting Japan's already-ailing economy. Hence, the short-lived "success" achieved by Japan actually spelt long-term disaster for its international ties.</p>

<p>Hence, from these examples drawn from literature and history, we can see that success may not in fact be as beneficial as imagined, for it may come at a tremendous cost to society or to ourselves in the long run. We should treat success with a pinch of salt, and evaluate its potential consequences before deciding if it is worth fighting for.</p>

<p><em>bumpitybump</em></p>

<p>so it’s a good essay, can you write it within the time constraints of the SAT?
I’d give it a 10-12</p>

<p>Thanks! Yep, I wrote it in 25 mins at home, hope I can do so under test conditions too.</p>

<p>25 minutes is cutting it pretty close, you might get a block at testing so make sure you write your essay within 18 minutes to be super duper saf</p>

<p>Alright, I’ve taken my SATs now, and… got an 8 for my essay. Bummer. :(</p>

<p>I will probably retake, and I’d like any advice at all on how to bump my essay up to an 11 or 12. You can critique my essay in the first post and/or my SAT essay below. All comments will be greatly appreciated - sentence structure, examples, writing style, length, anything! </p>

<h2>Here’s my SAT essay. What do you think went wrong? (I filled up 1 and 2/3 sides btw, 8/12.)</h2>

<p>Assignment: Would it be better if people were more accepting of mistakes?</p>

<p>In the mortal realm, no one is perfect, no matter how much one may try to be so. Human flaws inevitably form part of one’s character, and it would be to society’s benefit if we were more accepting of not just others’ mistakes, but also our own.</p>

<p>If everyone were perfect, we would lose our unique identities that form the diversity of society. In Aldous Huxley’s novel “Brave New World”, that is precisely the case - humans are genetically engineered at birth to suit their predetermined roles in society perfectly. As a result, any semblance of identity has been lost, with people becoming nothing more than mere automatons in a mechanically-run society. Only the protagonist, Bernard, suffers a physical flaw in that he is shorter than others in his caste - supposedly because he was wrongly imbued with alcohol at birth - however it is percisely his imeprfect nature that allowws readers to connect with him alone, and no one else in the faceless society. We sympathise with how he has become an outcast due to his imperfect as he grapples with society’s excessively high expectations. Hence, it is precisely such imperfections that give people their unique character, as depicted in the novel, so we should be more accepting of them.</p>

<p>Such a conclusion is not only relevant in the field of ltierature, but also in our real world today. I myself can be considered a perfectionist, unrelenting in my pursuit of an error-free existence. During examinations, I would set myself the goal of nothing less than a perfect grade, and if that was not to be, I would end up spending the rest of the day in a depressed state wallowing in self-pity. Eventually, I realised that I was doing nothing but giving myself unnecessary stress, and learnt to set myself more realistic targets. Not surprisingly, not only did my test scores rise after that epiphany, my spirits did, too. Hence, it was for the better that I became more accepting of my own mistakes.</p>

<h2>Settling for nothing less than perfection will create problems not just for society, but also for ourselves. As can be seen from the examples of literature and real life, it would be better if people were more accepting of mistakes, to allow for us to live not just easier, but also more colourful lives.</h2>

<p>Kinda ironic that I’m talking about how I’m a perfectionist in my essay, and here I am trying for a 12 isn’t it? :V</p>

<p><em>bumpitybump</em></p>