I am really glad to see this thread. I think it is very helpful for students and parents who are probably, at least initially, disappointed with a PSA decision.
One key take away - the freshman year of college flies by so quickly - way faster than anything in high school. The PSA year will be over before you know it.
It also highlights the need for students and parents to be very honest with themselves about if PSA is a good fit for their student. We donāt know the figures (and I have affection for cold hard stats), but we know that most people who start PSA do not end up at TAMU, despite the fact it appears to be a pretty straight forward process. It is probably less than 1/3 make it to College Station.
For what it is worth - here are my thoughts.
For driven, high achieving students with stats and scores like the folks tagged on this thread - PSA is just a slight detour on their goal.
But PSA is a āsoft-rejection.ā Meaning there is a HUGE spread in stats of the students offered PSA. Class rank and test scores do correlate with potential college success. That is why schools just them. Sure there are kids with great stats that wash out of college and there are scholars that were mediocre in high school that come to life in college. But those are the outliers.
So with the people doing PSA you have kids with solid stats like my daughter (pretty much academic admit to every state school except UT and TAMU - and I still canāt believe @JaceyK son got PSA with his stats.) and students in the bottom half of their class and ACT/SAT scores below the 50% range.
So you have a wide spread of past academic performance in the PSA program and the schools participating in PSA attract less academically proven students. I think @tisulli @chipndale touch on something exceedingly important. If you are going to participate in PSA - you need to be prepared to be a top performer and not go along with the crowd. Using Tarleton as an example.
Here is a look at the common data set freshman admission data.
Middle 50%
SAT
970-1150
ACT
18-23
With 33% of the students coming from the bottom 1/2 of their graduating class.
At TAMU
Middle 50%
SAT
1170-1380
ACT
25-31
With 1% of students coming from the bottom 1/2 of their graduating class.
If a student isnāt willing to go to the library when everyone around them is partying or not focused on academics, think long and hard about doing PSA. It can be really difficult hitting the books when everyone else seems to be out having a good time.