<p>
[quote]
The first thing I'd do is discourage the opinion/attitude that being around people with high SAT scores is the most desirable thing in the world.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>When you've been put on a pedestal and isolated from other people by other people for your entire life because you are smart, why on earth is it unreasonable to want to be around people like you, in a place where there will be no pedestal and less isolation? That was certainly one of my major motives for wanting to apply to "top" schools. Sure, I could have found other people like me at most colleges, but I wanted an environment where I would be the norm and not part of a small subset. I was sick to death of being the big fish. Having now gone through college and out the other side, I think I had absolutely the right idea (for me - YMMV).</p>
<p>I agree with almost everyone that it sounds like the OP's D is burnt out. Summer vacation can do wonders for that. It also sounds like she's too worked up about her future. I can relate...I remember feeling, in college, like nearly everyone else knew what direction they were going in and I didn't. Such things have a way of working themselves out, as long as one continues to investigate and prepare for possibilities.</p>
<p>She is afraid of making the "wrong" decision, so it might be helpful to point out to her that this isn't so black and white. There is not one "right" decision and all the rest are wrong. There aren't even many pure wrongs (and I am not convinced that there is such a thing as a pure right). Most schools will be "right" on some counts, and "wrong" on others.</p>