@Cherax
No one really knows how the admissions committee decides whom to admit.
Case Western like others follows a “process”. Process typically involves primary reviewers, secondary reviewers and Admissions Committee.
What weightage they give to which factors is more of an art and subjective - which is why we cannot figure out what exactly they are looking for.
In one of the threads, a medical student/professional had explained the process at his/her school in detail. I believe @rk2017 or @GoldenRock may have the link to that.
Also, note during this BS/MD admissions journey, you may come across a situation where a “lower” ranked university sends you a rejection but a “higher” ranked university sends you an interview invite.
So, stay patient and stop worrying about they colleges decide. It is OUT of our control.
Focus on sending your best application - this is within our control.