UC transfer personal statement - post, critiques, advice, etc.

<p>Congrats to all the transfers so far. I intend to apply this fall and I am working on several versions of my response to the 2nd prompt of the UC transfer essays. I am wondering what kinds of tips and advice everyone can give having been accepted or rejected from different UC's. What do you think worked? What perhaps did you do wrong? What did you focus on, and how did you present yourself?</p>

<p>I myself am having trouble with this essay. I have at least 4 different versions. I tend to be too narrative and dont know how to inject the "personal" aspect the prompt requests into the essay.</p>

<p>Take for example this that I just wrote:</p>

<p>I awoke before dawn and hesitantly washed myself with several cups of frigid water, the surface of which had hardened into a transparent film of cracked ice. A shrill moo near the washroom window crisply cut through the still air and startled me in my half-awake stupor. In India, the cows moo and their bells rattle inharmoniously before the roosters coo. I dried off and threw on a royal blue kurta that seemed to exhibit its own luminescence in the darkness. I slipped into my baggy white trousers and moaned at the pain in my soles. The day before, a boisterous Sadhu had taken my sandals while I was washing my feet on the steps of a small Hare Krishna temple. It was a serendipitous encounter that left my Grandmother, who was my chaperone, crying from laughter, like it was a prank she had played before. We were after all in her home village that according to my travel guide did not exist, so perhaps taking sandals was an idiosyncratic custom here that my grandmother neglected to inform me of. Eccentricity and peculiarity are the essence of the Indian national identity – why should I expect anything else here, at the fringes of civilization?</p>

<p>“Kale!” he laughed while pointing his long, dry finger at me. The overprotective foreigner and territorial big-city macho part of me wanted to lash out and snatch them back. Instead I used a blend of my limited knowledge of Gujurati, Hindi, and Marathi to talk with him and discern his intentions, though it was through my grandmother’s assistance that we came to a consensus. He wanted to be sure we would meet again, and we agreed to meet at the temple the following morning. I repeatedly looked to my grandmother to clarify the who, what, and why that I so desperately required knowing regarding this man and his objective. She avoided answering and encouraged me to play along. “Kale,” I said with an aura of foreboding, wagging my finger at him in admonition. </p>

<p>Stones, dung, and prickly plants berated my poor soles the whole day as we walked from place to place. I was shocked at my grandmother’s incredulous and uncharacteristic lack of concern. I was in pain, and she had refused to purchase new sandals for me. A few villagers offered me theirs that I refused because I believed a ‘thank you’ was inadequate compensation for the poor. An old, crooked woman convinced me to let her wrap them in some clothe powdered with turmeric, and her husband actually forced me to ride his cow and he escorted me the rest of the day until we returned home. I did not know why people there were so caring about a stranger, or why they were so persistent, but I was humbled by their kindness.</p>

<p>To my surprise that morning, I found the man who had accompanied me with his cow waiting outside. In a fury of gestures and monosyllabic English I learned he was to take me to the temple. When we arrived, the Sadhu was there waiting. He smiled, waived, and walked over to me, handing me my beloved sandles. I felt like a wounded veteran reunited with his wife. He held me and stunned me when he spoke unbroken English. “This is my home, these are my friends. This is yours, too. We share our food, homes, and lessons.” He said, pointing to my wrapped feet. “We are happy this way, do you see? – Indeed, there was nothing but joy and friendliness here. “We struggle for the same, for warmth, comfort, and food, and we help each other to obtain this. Remember when you go back to USA – you have seen another way to live and be happy.” </p>

<p>I later learned that the Sadhu was a prominent figure in OSHO, a former physics professor, and that my grandmother’s is his disciple. He had planned to make an impact on me that I would never forget. He succeeded in showing me love, joy, reality, and possibility. Though the time was short, I lived in their shoes and found relations with people I had originally thought I had nothing in common with. I learned the value of propriety and openness through my encounter with the Sadhu. My grandmother’s pitiless frugality was a lesson in necessity over desires and the resourcefulness of a community. Humility and lightheartedness are the keys to happiness that sustained these people, and I have adopted these to my own benefit. Everyday that I trudge to work and school, I am reminded that although I have “walked the walk”, my journey is far from over. </p>

<p>SO
I'm looking for some input from you all. What does this essay miss? MOre generally, what's your interpretation and inference from this. I feel like all i did was tell a story, and it says very little about me other than that I spent time in India and had an experience that was influencing. </p>

<p>Perhaps Ill share my others depending on the enthusiasm of you all. </p>

<p>Take down your essay, you don’t want anyone to copy your material. There were many cases of such happening. You can ask members of this forum for opinions via private messages. </p>

<p>tl;dr</p>

<p>You seem like a good writer, but you need to talk about yourself more. This is a fine story and everything, but I still don’t know much about you from reading this. It also seems a little bit corny, and like you’re trying to make yourself out to be the most gracious, perfect person ever. Also, I think the admissions officers have heard the “privileged kid visits poor country because he cares so much” story enough. That’s just my opinion though. Good luck.</p>

<p>@CSB111 Is having the attention span of a goldfish something you want to advertise? :stuck_out_tongue: </p>

<p>@music1990 how do I make it personal? like what should i be sounding like? what type of language do I use? i have always sucked at personal essays.</p>

<p>Well I am by no means an authority on personal statements, but I’ll give you the best advice I can. Think about it as a self reflection, using stories to support your reflections. So instead of focusing on what happened to you, focus on your thought process during that experience. Your main goal is to show them who you are, not tell a story. You can of course tell a story, but that should come secondary to your portrayal of yourself. In your story, I feel like I know more about the other characters in your story then you.</p>

<p>Also, think of a characteristic about yourself, and try to emphasize it throughout the essay. Don’t be afraid to just come out and say it, also. For example: “I have always considered myself very persistent when it comes to reaching my goals” (a little bit of a cliche, but you get it). Then talk about an experience that showcases that quality.</p>

<p>@captaincal what’s your major?</p>

<p>If you want your reader to care about your experience with the “boisterous Sadhu” and it’s significance to you (and you do), you need to tell them more about who you are.</p>

<p>You don’t need to fill every sentence with awkward vocabulary, such as “boisterous” or “monosyllabic”. Keep it simple. You want the reader to hear the authenticity of your voice. </p>

<p>music1990 is right. You give more detail to the other characters than you do about yourself. We want to know why this experience is important to you. </p>

<p>I’m an English major and published a lot of writing the last 15 years. I wanted to say that first to possibly validate my thoughts. My first thought is, I couldn’t get past the first paragraph. You’re trying WAY too hard here. They want to hear your voice, not the prose of some amateur fiction writer. I know this is not fiction, but it reads like a bad intro to a poorly written novel. I don’t want to discourage you, there’s plenty here to work with. You just need to use your voice to articulate the essentials, stop writing short fiction, and start answering the prompts with a little more clarity and a little less pomp.</p>

<p>Good luck! :)</p>

<p>Well I only glanced at the first, which actually has a lot of great potential, but you have wayyyyy too many adjectives and unnecessary description. It’s not reading like you. It’s reading like someone with a thesaurus trying too hard. Take this line for example: “prickly plants berated my poor soles…” </p>

<p>REALLY?</p>

<p>Start over and just tell your slice of life in your own words. No thesaurus. No thousands of adjectives. </p>

<p>Also, like someone said, don’t post online anymore. But that first story has potential. I would stick with it and work hard refining it.</p>

<p>Go to your school’s transfer center and see if they have any admission officers that come in from UCLA or UC Berkeley. Talk to them, get to know them, and find out what they’re looking for. Personally, it was immensely helpful because I went over numerous drafts of my personal statement with an actual admission officer. </p>

<p>I would say you should try to retell that story, but tell it is if you are talking to your friend. Just tell the story of what happened, how you felt ,where you went, and just talk. Imagine as if your friend is asking you questions in the middle, and then you go back and answer their questions. It will come out originally too long and too wordy, but then you can go back and edit and make it shorter and more appropriate for your essay. </p>

<p>Don’t write the way you think an educated college student should sound, write is if you were actually talking to real people. In my opinion, a more conversational style essay is most effective. It gives the audience the best idea of who you really are. They want students, not robots.</p>

<p>Kudos for starting so early. I’ll just add on to what everyone else has said and this might be a repetition of what the others said but that just tells you how important it is, right?</p>

<p>You should more explicitly state what you’ve gained from that experience and how you’ve changed throughout your walk.I think that you shouldn’t show so much what was happening around you, but how the villager’s kindness affected you and changed you.</p>

<p>State why you’re proud of this walk.</p>

<p>Ultimately, I suggest that you need to show how you’ve grown out of that experience and how the consequences around you personally/emotionally affected you.</p>

<p>Yea, this is definitely a story. I made the same mistake as you, and I pretty much had to start from scratch after showing it to one of the teachers that helped with personal statements. You need to reflect on how this story has affected you way more than actually telling it. What you learned from it, how it changed you, etc…<br>
Good news is you have like a 5 month head start so definitely take your time, use help at your school, and read sample essays and see how they talk about themselves rather than describing an event. </p>

<p>I read this a couple nights ago, just read a bit of again. I see you are trying to write the perfect paper. But it honestly looks forced. It appears to be a story rather than your own statement. It needs to be a free-flowing essay that is easy to read. Some of your lingo, it does seem you are on thesaurus.com and looking for the perfect word. This isn’t really a research paper, so, just start over, and write and write. Write from the heart, do not look for the perfect word that you believe will win over the reader. These people are pros and see thousands papers a year. </p>