<p>I am sorry but the coment on “quirky humor” put me over the top.</p>
<p>W&M Admissions isn’t quirky the are epitome of smarmy and self indulgent.</p>
<p>As you might guess my daughter wasn’t accepted after going early decision and having her heart set on W&M for a couple of years so I have an edge on. She got a curtesy wait list at ED and then denied RD.</p>
<p>She comes from a small school in NoVa and was the classic “good citizen” candidate with weak SAT’s.</p>
<p>Her profile was as follows:</p>
<p>GPA: 3.9 Unweighted
SAT: 1290
ACT: 28
Varsity Soccer Four Years, Captain Junior and Senior Years
Varsity Basketball Four Years, Captain Junior and Senior Years
Varsity Vollyball Four Years, Captain Senior Year
Varsity Cross Country Senior Year, 23rd out of 220 runners in VA Independent School State Meet (she ran this part time in the Fall while playing Volly Ball and travel soccer)
Washington Area Girls Soccer League - Premier Washington area travel league through out HS
Tutored Underclassmen in Algebra annually
Worked part time job managing local parish gym during CYO basketball season
Worked in Summer Bible Camps for local parish
Editor and Photographer for HS Yearbook Four Years
Leader of HS Service Org
Etc, etc</p>
<p>She has received Presidential Scholarships (or similar from Saint Joseph’s, Shenandoah University, Catholic University, Randolph, Randolph Macon, Duquesne.</p>
<p>She made a preliminary application to the Naval Academy after being named camper of the week at their soccer camp and had her phone ringing off the hook from the Blue/Gold Officer assigned to her encouraging her to apply because of her leadership attributes.</p>
<p>But I knew the true tenor of W&M when she went for her interview last summer. The kid doing the interview was originally from South Dakota and only applied to W&M “because it was easy to click the Common App button.” You could tell he had his and he was being pretty superior about holding some role in deciding who got theirs. After the interview it was clear from the sneer in his face that my D wasn’t up to snuff for him. After talking to my daughter I could tell that she had been too open and without guile with him. When she emailed several months later with a question and comment about whether the interviewers kept track of the percentage of folks they interviewed that actually applied or got admitted, he never responded. </p>
<p>Two kids from her school were accepted to W&M. No legacy, no ECs of consequence, lower or equal GPA’s just stratospheric boards and they were male. A Lebanese friend or hers from another school didn’t crack 1200 in the boards, a 3.5 GPA with no honors and had no EC’s to speak of; accepted.</p>
<p>All the baloney about the holistic approach to class selection is just that. If you are white, and female you better have a lead on the cure for cancer to be assured of admittence. All Henry B’s kumbaya goes out the window and they rank order the SAT’s.</p>
<p>My D was accepted to a number of six year DPT Programs which is were she is focusing on at this point. So when the PolySci majors get out of W&M looking for jobs or their parents to pay for grad school, she will be on track to be a Doctor of Physical Therapy and have a profession within two years. </p>
<p>I am sorry we ever applied.</p>