What made them miserable?

<p>Warning: long. But you all have been so supportive and concerned that I wanted to let you know how things are going. </p>

<p>D has turned herself around. She is definitely returning next semester, and over the break was talking about what her major might be, possibilities for her study-abroad semester, and was heard to use the word “friend” in reference to someone at school. Oh, and she casually mentioned that she has set herself the goal of being her class’s valedictorian. She hasn’t spoken the words, but apparently she intends to stay. </p>

<p>So what caused this 180? We haven’t asked, because we’re pretending we never doubted, and we don’t want to put her in the position of having to explain her earlier histrionics. Someday I will probe, but not now. It didn’t hurt that her advisor guided her toward a “killer schedule” (D’s phrase; killer in a good way) of alluring classes for spring semester. Or that her workstudy bosses are going out of their way to make her job fun (e.g., she spent an entire afternoon alphabetizing a wall of books in one of the prof’s offices, which apparently is the best task anyone could ever be assigned). But I think it really began with a committee, of all things. </p>

<p>Early on, she joined the school’s dance group, and was soon drafted onto the steering committee. (I suspect the long arm of the Freshman Dean here; she had mobilized half the campus for the D Outreach Project.) D was given a small assignment by the committee which utilized some of her past dance experience, and the kid took that assignment and ran with it. The first thing she did was call me for some information she needed, and it was the very first call which did not include the words “I hate this place.” Apparently the committee liked her work and gave her lots of praise which inspired her to further heights of committee work. At one point she texted, “The convenors LOVE me!” </p>

<p>This happened a few days before Halloween, but then came the Halloween party drama. The co-chair of the committee (a senior!) invited D to go with her to a school party/dance; it was to be D’s very first social outing. At first she was excited and we had several hours’ worth of intense discussion about costumes. As the time drew near though, she began to lose her nerve. Despite my best efforts, she had pretty much decided to spend yet another Saturday night alone in her room when, of all people, her boyfriend out here in California stepped into the fray and persuaded her to go. Bless him! When we asked about it later, she said “Oh. Yes, I went, it was fun.” Just like that. So casual, as if the previous 2 months of misery had never happened.</p>

<p>But apparently that broke the ice for her, that and the committee. My guess is that being on that committee has made her feel that she’s making a contribution to something which others value. Or maybe she feels like she’s finally “inside” a group, and one which has a pretty high profile on campus at that. After feeling so rejected and alone, it must be balm to her soul. And it has one perk – members get a special sweatshirt with the committee name on the front and the student’s name in BIG letters on the back. She wore that thing almost continually when she was home for break, and I imagine wears it alot at school too. I think it says “I’m somebody.”</p>

<p>At Thanksgiving, she went to see her old therapist, and the first thing she said afterward was, “Nate said that his first semester was alot like my first semester, and he turned out fine.” It was a revelation seemingly; I refrained from reminding her that during her rough time, quite a few people had told her the same thing. Instead, I nodded wisely and said, “You know, I think alot of people do. In fact, I think what you’ve been going through is actually the norm” and she agreed. Which is really the bottom-line change. For 2 months, the main source of her unhappiness was that she thought she was the only one, and could not be convinced otherwise. Now she understands that there’s nothing odd about her experience. She still has some settling in to do there, and doesn’t yet have anyone who could be described as a close friend, although she is establishing some friendly acquaintances. But she finally knows that she’s on the same track with everyone else, and that makes all the difference. As so many of you said, she just needed to give it a little time, and she needed to find her people, and she has now done both.</p>

<p>Someday, possibly during senior year when she’s looking toward her next step in life, we’ll go back over this experience and see what she can learn from it, and how she can better handle other major transitions. Then again, maybe she won’t need our help at all; she’s a smart kid (future valedictorian, you know!) so she’ll probably figure it out on her own.</p>

<p>I didn’t post about this sooner because I wanted to look D in the eye over Thanksgiving to make sure it was real, and it seems to be. My heartfelt thanks to you for listening to my earlier rants, and for your wonderful support, sympathy and suggestions. I now feel qualified as an expert on the subject of miserable freshmen, so I hope I can give the same helping hand next year if it’s needed.</p>

<p>I think most of the unhappiness occurs in the first semester, and is due to loneliness. It takes awhile to deepen any connections to the point that they are satisfying, and previous connections (high school friends, for instance) are not available during the transition (at least in person).</p>

<p>LasMa, thank you for that update. What wonderful, encouraging news. The school sounds great too.</p>

<p>Lasma, long is fine. I was just sitting down for the first cup of coffee (5;30am here). Glald to hear everything is better. Sounds like a great school. I’m sure that helping hand will be needed re: miserable freshman next year. Be ready :)</p>

<p>LasMa, I’m delighted and really thank you for sharing your story. I might need to call on your expertise next year! Wow, what a supportive college. I might PM you to get the name!</p>

<p>So great to hear LasMa! - though not for everyone (my S is one who would be appalled to attend) a small LAC can truly open doors to the world for some. There are many who have amazing things to offer, such as your D, who can get overwhelmed by the transition into college, thank goodness the small LACs are here - I am a devoted fan. My D had a very parallel first semester to yours and so I followed your posts with great attention - her small LAC has been phenomenal in helping her get to her inner strength - so she can get to sharing her unique abilities - and without officially asking for help, either at her end or ours.</p>

<p>My D found the right school and has been happy there from the beginning. Choosing to live on a floor with others in her major for her first year was a huge plus. She’s a sophomore. She is 3000 miles from home and has been homesick only during the first few days of her freshman year. Loved high school, but was never a really social person - never asked to a dance, always a good girl. Found her fun side in college. Living in a dorm again this year and is happier than ever.</p>

<p>One of her closest friends from high school went to the same school, lived in the same dorm, and was totally miserable freshman year. Completely withdrew from D, because she was so uncomfortable with being unhappy. Wanted to come home the entire time, but parents stuck to their guns and made her wait it out. Now she lives off campus in a house with friends and is very happy.</p>

<p>Friend #3 was the “it” girl from kindergarten through 12th grade. Never had an awkward moment, never missed a school dance or party - boys flocked to her, girls loved her. Went to very popular party school with lots of “it” girls, and completely fell apart. She didn’t stand out anymore, and couldn’t deal with it (talked to me about this over Thanksgiving). Parents acquiesced and she came home after first semester and has regretted it ever since - going to CC and lonely and bored. Now she blames her parents for not taking a firmer stand about her staying - and her mother feels terrible that she gave in so easily.</p>

<p>Moral: DON’T let your kids come home freshman year if you can possibly avoid it. Its a huge transition that sometimes is heart-wrenching for parents to hear about and painful for kids to get through.</p>

<p>LasMa – As one of those who has followed your daughter’s story on other threads, I was so pleased to find this post and the news of your daughter’s “turnaround.” What a hopeful turn of events for all of you!</p>

<p>happy to hear the good news. Thanks for the update. :)</p>

<p>LasMa-Great news. I’m so happy for you and your D.</p>

<p>Oh, LasMa, I am definitely saving your posts for reference. My daughter, also a California girl and almost an “only child” (has grown sisters sixteen years older)…and kind of “spoiled” sounds a lot like your D. Her first choice school is OOS 2,000 miles away and she’s bound and determined to go there (has been accepted). Of course, we’ll see how it works financially. But, like your daughter, mine has this idea of a “perfect school”. She wants a traditional campus with older buildings and just that whole “ivy-covered wall look”. It has to have the rah-rah aspect and a very college-friendly town or city surrounding it. Good academics and sports programs. Ranked, but not necessarily at the very top. She prefers a larger student population with ways to make the school seem smaller. Okay, fine. She hasn’t found her “perfect college” in CA yet (based on short tours, many of them in the summer). Oh, sure, she’s seen a school that has the pretty campus and older brick buildings…but the city stinks (not literally :slight_smile: Or she’s found a couple great college towns…but she doesn’t care for the campuses. Arrrghhh. SO—she decided her “perfect school” is 2,000 miles away! Very different climate. The state, itself, is fairly conservative, although the campus and town are more liberal. This school fits everything she’s looking for in a college. Big campus with gorgeous architecture and landcaping. Rah-rah, sports-oriented. Good academics. The major she wants. Fun, small college town. The whole enchilada.</p>

<p>I should be happy for her, right? (that is if we find it affordable and she ends up attending.) Well, after reading your posts, as well as others here, it makes me wonder if my daughter’s expectations will be met in the end. Will her “perfect school” look and feel the same to her as it did in the pictures or when she read all the positive reviews? Just reading about your daughter makes me wonder if mine will have some of the same feelings.</p>

<p>Well, all we can do is wait and see. I hate to be selfish and insist she stay in state just because of my own fears that she’ll be let down with her OOS “perfect school”. She could very well feel the same way if she attended a college 2 hours away. </p>

<p>It’s never easy, is it? :)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>LasMa, I need to meet your D and rave over the joy of alphabetizing books. :smiley: Has she ever considered library school?</p>

<p>Great to hear that she’s managed to get through the brunt of the transition.</p>

<p>To LasMa: Two thumbs up to your daughter and to YOU for hanging in there!! This gives me hope for the future should my own daughter have any of the same issues when she goes off to college.</p>

<p>Thank you!</p>

<hr>

<p>LasMa had written:</p>

<p>Update on D </p>

<hr>

<p>Warning: long. But you all have been so supportive and concerned that I wanted to let you know how things are going. </p>

<p>D has turned herself around. She is definitely returning next semester, and over the break was talking about what her major might be, possibilities for her study-abroad semester, and was heard to use the word “friend” in reference to someone at school. Oh, and she casually mentioned that she has set herself the goal of being her class’s valedictorian. She hasn’t spoken the words, but apparently she intends to stay. </p>

<p>So what caused this 180? We haven’t asked, because we’re pretending we never doubted, and we don’t want to put her in the position of having to explain her earlier histrionics. Someday I will probe, but not now. It didn’t hurt that her advisor guided her toward a “killer schedule” (D’s phrase; killer in a good way) of alluring classes for spring semester. Or that her workstudy bosses are going out of their way to make her job fun (e.g., she spent an entire afternoon alphabetizing a wall of books in one of the prof’s offices, which apparently is the best task anyone could ever be assigned). But I think it really began with a committee, of all things. </p>

<p>Early on, she joined the school’s dance group, and was soon drafted onto the steering committee. (I suspect the long arm of the Freshman Dean here; she had mobilized half the campus for the D Outreach Project.) D was given a small assignment by the committee which utilized some of her past dance experience, and the kid took that assignment and ran with it. The first thing she did was call me for some information she needed, and it was the very first call which did not include the words “I hate this place.” Apparently the committee liked her work and gave her lots of praise which inspired her to further heights of committee work. At one point she texted, “The convenors LOVE me!” </p>

<p>This happened a few days before Halloween, but then came the Halloween party drama. The co-chair of the committee (a senior!) invited D to go with her to a school party/dance; it was to be D’s very first social outing. At first she was excited and we had several hours’ worth of intense discussion about costumes. As the time drew near though, she began to lose her nerve. Despite my best efforts, she had pretty much decided to spend yet another Saturday night alone in her room when, of all people, her boyfriend out here in California stepped into the fray and persuaded her to go. Bless him! When we asked about it later, she said “Oh. Yes, I went, it was fun.” Just like that. So casual, as if the previous 2 months of misery had never happened.</p>

<p>But apparently that broke the ice for her, that and the committee. My guess is that being on that committee has made her feel that she’s making a contribution to something which others value. Or maybe she feels like she’s finally “inside” a group, and one which has a pretty high profile on campus at that. After feeling so rejected and alone, it must be balm to her soul. And it has one perk – members get a special sweatshirt with the committee name on the front and the student’s name in BIG letters on the back. She wore that thing almost continually when she was home for break, and I imagine wears it alot at school too. I think it says “I’m somebody.”</p>

<p>At Thanksgiving, she went to see her old therapist, and the first thing she said afterward was, “Nate said that his first semester was alot like my first semester, and he turned out fine.” It was a revelation seemingly; I refrained from reminding her that during her rough time, quite a few people had told her the same thing. Instead, I nodded wisely and said, “You know, I think alot of people do. In fact, I think what you’ve been going through is actually the norm” and she agreed. Which is really the bottom-line change. For 2 months, the main source of her unhappiness was that she thought she was the only one, and could not be convinced otherwise. Now she understands that there’s nothing odd about her experience. She still has some settling in to do there, and doesn’t yet have anyone who could be described as a close friend, although she is establishing some friendly acquaintances. But she finally knows that she’s on the same track with everyone else, and that makes all the difference. As so many of you said, she just needed to give it a little time, and she needed to find her people, and she has now done both.</p>

<p>Someday, possibly during senior year when she’s looking toward her next step in life, we’ll go back over this experience and see what she can learn from it, and how she can better handle other major transitions. Then again, maybe she won’t need our help at all; she’s a smart kid (future valedictorian, you know!) so she’ll probably figure it out on her own.</p>

<p>I didn’t post about this sooner because I wanted to look D in the eye over Thanksgiving to make sure it was real, and it seems to be. My heartfelt thanks to you for listening to my earlier rants, and for your wonderful support, sympathy and suggestions. I now feel qualified as an expert on the subject of miserable freshmen, so I hope I can give the same helping hand next year if it’s needed.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>2Leashes: No, it really isn’t! Regarding closer-to-home colleges for your D, obviously I can’t advise you, but this issue came up over and over during this saga. D really was convinced that it was the 1500 miles that made it so difficult for her, but I’m not so sure. I think that the real problem was that she just wasn’t ready to be on her own, and that would have been the case no matter where she was. In fact, I think that the first step to her turnaround was when she finally faced the fact that, for better or worse, she was stuck there until Thanksgiving. If she’d had the option of escaping home regularly, it might have been even easier for her to remain isolated, and drawn out the thing even further. As painful as it was for her and for us, I think it was really a blessing in disguise that she couldn’t come home on weekends. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Keilexandra: Hahaa, I can see the appeal of sorting through books as well! She says she’s not interested in library sciences, although she might change her mind – her job sometimes takes her into the Quaker archives maintained by the college, and she seems to really like that as well. But her latest thing is the discovery that they offer a minor in museum sciences, which seems like it may have similarities. I can definitely see her as a curator some day.</p>

<p>I think it’s important to talk with your child about the realities of college (eg. there will be lots of work, not a lot of privacy, roommate to deal with, some boring profs as well as some great profs, noise in the dorms), but that they are SO LUCKY to be able to go. In regards to schools, it helps if the school has a really strong orientation program that works on building “community” before school starts. Both my kids were so happy to be at their school, and there was no “miserable” - in part because the weeklong orientation program that groups 7-8 students with 2 upperclassmen advisors and initiates the kids into the school culture. LASMA, I’m so glad your daughter stuck it out, and that she is finding her place there now. :)</p>

<p>LasMa, I am so happy for you and D. Here’s to you both!</p>

<p>LasMa-thank you so much for the update! </p>

<p>I am so very glad for your daughter and for you! She has no idea probably of how her misery affected you. </p>

<p>You are an amazing Mom…she probably can’t appreciate that right now either, but I hope you know it!</p>

<p>LasMa…so happy that your daughter has come out on the other side. It must have been so difficult for you. </p>

<p>You did a great job supporting her, and don’t let anyone tell you that “if only you had done…” or “if only she had been…”…sometimes these things just happen and there is no predicting or preventing them.</p>

<p>LasMa - Wonderful news for your family!!</p>