What to do when you think your son is truly not ready for college?

<p>To the op- my heart goes out to you. You sound like a terrific parent.</p>

<p>I want to add one quick thought to the advice you've already gotten here.... your son will not change as long as he is trying to "make you proud" as you indicated in one of your posts. The point is not to make you proud; the point is for him to find direction and satisfaction and meaning in what he's doing for HIM- not for you, or for your H, or for anyone else.</p>

<p>As a very bright child he may well have absorbed the message that there is one way and one path- a good college, a professional job, so it's either perfectionism or don't even try- and right now he's chosen the latter path. Part of your job now, both in helping him get to college and to stay in college, is to support him as he learns that there are many paths; that working hard to get a C in a tough class is a wonderful thing; that succeeding in a physical/blue collar type job is something to be proud of; that just getting up and getting to work on time is half the battle. There are grownups right now working as forest rangers and coast guards and air traffic controllers and electricians and nurses and chefs and animal rescue workers.... and they are all heros to someone whom they've helped or saved. You don't need to be in a prestigious law school to make mommy and daddy proud.</p>

<p>I am fearful of parents who describe their almost adult children as "wanting to make us proud". Your pride should come from him fulfilling HIS goals and not yours. For a kid with an addiction and other demons he's been battling, it is indeed a daunting task to try and make someone else proud. Far easier for you to help him make himself proud.</p>

<p>What does HE want?</p>

<p>blossom, I asked that in post no. 19 but didn't get a response.</p>

<p>I thought I made it clear.....but let me say again, HE DOES WANT TO GO TO COLLEGE VERY MUCH. He totally recognizes his chances and opportunities and doesn't want to blow it down the drain. He wants to go into business and international relations (what he is going to scool for) and is very much wanting to still pursue that path.
You don't know me, and I can't expect you to know this, but I am the very last person to expect any of my kids/stepkids to follow "my path" or whatever road I envision for them. I am the first to lay out the red carpet for them to go and find THEIR dreams, I only ask that they follow truly what is in their hearts, I always tell them find something that excites you, something that you can't wait to wake up in the morning to do, there is no cookie cutter for life, and my kids are no exceptions. I have offered for him to take a year off, work, do something to ponder his life and what he should do, he has made it clear he wants to go to college and study business.
Also please again make no assumptions- We will be doing backflips to see him proud of himself and noone else, nothing could make my heart burst more with pride than seeing that. I think some of what I am saying is being misinterpeted or misconstrued............I believe in allowing them to be who they want to be with no walls to cage them in and no expectations, other than to hopefully take full advantage of the opportunities we are able to provide them.
With response to someone else implying that we are cavalier about the pot use, NO we are most certainly not. Around here, it is as common as drinking and is everywhere.....we are very on top of this and as of the last almost 2 weeks I can with certainty he has done it. He admits he does it only when he is bored and/or when he hangs around a certain few kids, whom we have banned from our house. He did have some money from graduation, which my husband has since put into a bank account.</p>

<p>OOPS^ I meant he has NOT smoked pot in the last two weeks!!:/</p>

<p>If it were my kid, I'd be testing him for pot on a regular basis - a clean report (probably monthly) would be required for A) to get any money for college or B) being allowed to live in our home during breaks and summers. I'd be following up with monthly tests for at least 6 months - with the right to ask for a sample at any time while he still needs our money or our roof. Zero compromise. </p>

<p>Your son has an addictive personality. You need to set a hard limit WITH VERIFICATION (unless you are testing, you simply can not know for certain - saying otherwise is foolish).</p>

<p>Be sure to also write a contract with a certain GPA for college (so it isn't a wishy-washy one open for interpretation) in order to keep your financial support.</p>

<p>Good luck,</p>

<p>Annika</p>

<p>CT Mom, sorry if I offended you. However, you are posting on a message board presumably asking for alternative points of view to the one you and H already have. If all you want is for us to affirm that you are right-- well go walk the dog and get an answer from him.</p>

<p>You have asked us whether your fears about your son being away from home are realistic ones.... and many of us have responded that yes, we think your fears are quite real given the facts you chosen to post. You may be wishing for the college fairy to come and say, 'oh no, every young man goes through this and ends up a Rhodes scholar or graduates summa cum laude after a final summer at home smoking weed and getting fired from a job with a family member, so don't you worry about his initiative one iota.'</p>

<p>Well, I'm sure there are men out there who have done exactly that. Far more common is the pattern of the kid not quite ready for college who moves into a dorm where there is a party going on 24/7, where someone is always willing to play computer games rather than go to Chem lab, where a bunch of guys are ready to teach your son online poker, using the money you thought was going for books and food.</p>

<p>Don't want to hear that? then don't post here. Kids who drop out or who demonstrate that they're not ready for college are all different in many, many ways.... but you have signaled to us in more way than one that your son may or may not be ready for college.... but it would definitely be a concern.</p>

<p>And when he blew off job number 1 with a family member, why did you help him get job number 2 with a family member? Why not your local Dunkin Donuts or Walmart greeter? Why so eager and ready to dig him out of the hole he dug himself into by getting fired for not showing up? How does this teach him that actions have consequences????</p>

<p>ct, sorry if I offended with my question. I truly didn't see that he wanted to go away to college above. I only asked because I wanted to find a way that each of you could get something you wanted.</p>

<p>Because he wants to go to college but seems unprepared, I wholeheartedly endorse northeastmom's plan (I think it was her; that was a long time ago)! of allowing him to go but with a written set of consequences if he fails to meet the minimum standards you and dh set. While I'm not sure he'll meet your expectations, I'm also not convinced he'll fail. Sometimes the bird needs to be pushed out of the nest in order to try those wings.</p>

<p>And he'd be getting not one red cent from me this summer for entertainment the way he treated a relative trying to help out. Grrrr.</p>

<p>I'm a mom with a senior daughter. I write not about her, but about my own brother.</p>

<p>Brother is the youngest of three kids and the only one of us to get mixed up with drugs and the wrong crowd. This was hard on everyone.</p>

<p>When college time came for him, my parents didn't know what to do. Back in that day, most people in our area marched off to the local large public university. That is what my parents did for my brother. </p>

<p>Despite saying he wanted to make something of myself, he continued the drug use and got horrific grades. I don't know whether he dropped out of college or was thrown out. He wound up working in the toy department of Kmart. Still using drugs, being rather bummy, getting a girl pregnant, marrying her, being a lousy dad . . . </p>

<p>One day, he looked at himself and said "Enough." He had a religious conversion, cleaned up his act. Enrolled in a different large local university, had to re-take a bunch of stuff to get a passing grade.</p>

<p>Graduated, got a job in computer networking. Started making good money.</p>

<p>Fast forward: Three healthy children, 20-plus year marriage to their mom, good career, devout in his religion, active in his church, good family relations all around. He is now a middle-aged man driving a Miata. :)</p>

<p>I say this because I think the lesson is that people will not change until <em>they</em> hit rock bottom. There is nothing anyone else can do to push them toward rock bottom; all we can do is delay it, to everyone's detriment. My parents refused to support my brother and pay his tuition when he was doing the wrong things, understand that college is not a magic bullet. College is something that mentally healthy and prepared people do. </p>

<p>To the OP, I would ask yourself a really hard question: If you send your son and he underperforms, will you have the guts it takes to cut him off and refuse to fund him further? Have you ever cut him off, said no, put your foot down?</p>

<p>You are going to have to draw the line somewhere, someday. Do understand that drawing the line sooner rather than later can allow a child to turn things around of their own accord. </p>

<p>It it were me, I would think it is not enough for him to <em>say</em> he wants to go to college. He would have to <em>show</em> he wants to go. By using that one-year deferment to best advantage.</p>

<p>If it were me, I would tell him that you're not willing to fund his college at this time, and you'd like him to take a year and show you that he is a different person. (If he chooses to attend anyway, you can always tell him to take out loans, etc.). I wouldn't fool around with any "Outward Bound" type programs, unless it is something <em>he</em> suggests he wants or needs. </p>

<p>Perhaps taking a stand will be the wake-up call he needs. I somehow believe that sending him to college (more drugs, less supervision, no rules) is a recipe for disaster.</p>

<p>I just hope you keep all of us posted with his progress. I am sure others find themselves in this or a similar position and will benefit from your experience as time goes on. I will look forward to your post in about 5 or 6 months telling us all that he did fine and made it through the first semester without falling prey to hardships. No one knows a kid like their mom does and I am sure all of this discussion has forced you to really clarify to yourself what you think and what direction you want him to move in. Good luck!</p>

<p>I really disagree strongly with the people who are suggesting a one-year deferment from college from a kid who WANTS to go to college now. I just can't see what would happen in that year except more tension at home and a kid who was bored & frustrated with a menial job. </p>

<p>I also disagree with those who are equating occasional pot use with hard-scale addiction. Maybe it is a regional, cultural thing -- like ctmom I am in an area where pot use is pretty common, starting in middle school. I honestly am much more concerned about alcohol use than pot -- for a variety of reasons, including the fact that I think alcohol is far more likely to result in addiction. Yes, there are many potheads who overindulge, but there are far more alcoholics. </p>

<p>I don't know ctmom's son, but "addiction" to gaming is very different than addiction to substances -- so it is a mistake to equate the two.</p>

<p>It is possible that ctmom's son is going to run into problems at college, but it is also possible that college will be the first place where he really feels engaged and validated. </p>

<p>I think ctmom is right to nudge her son out of the house and into a job during the summer, and I definitely think there should be a clear set of rules set for college -- but I don't think the college rules should be tied too closely to behavior. It's impossible for a parent to monitor the behavior of a kid living away from home in any event. Rather, it needs to be tied to results which can be easily verified, such as a minimum GPA. </p>

<p>The idea is to make parental expectations clear, give the kid the opportunity to succeed and at the same time make it clear that mommy and daddy are not going to fix things for him this time around if he fails. Too many parental rules and too much interference only makes it harder to "succeed" -- so I personally found it much more effective with my kids to set the bar low, but set it in a way that was non-negotiable.</p>

<p>calmom has expressed my thoughts better than I could have myself. No one can know in advance how her son will respond to college life, but it seems to me that he should not lose the opportunity to go (with defined expectations).</p>

<p>I know a couple of great kids, top students, who fell apart during the last half of senior year. One of them, after early admission to a top LAC, was in danger of not graduating because he was not turning in assignments (very uncharacteristic of him). Another was having anxiety attacks. It's a turning point, and not everyone can take it in stride.</p>

<p>If you check ctmom's history (as she invited us to do), you will find she has started <em>over 100</em> threads related to her own son's college admittance. This is since October of 2007. </p>

<p>Two major threads dealt with addiction to WOW and one to Halo.</p>

<p>An April 16 post said "I have spoken to him about addressing the addictive nature of his personality and we agreed that he will see a therapist."</p>

<p>I did not see ctmom address this in this thread, so I hope I'm safe in assuming that though she has acknowledged the son's addictive personality, she has not carried through on the counseling.</p>

<p>I was a first generation college student myself. My own brother did not go to school directly after high school as I did; he worked at "menial" jobs until his late twenties when he finally went to school for an associates degree, which enabled him to make a better living.</p>

<p>I have to question how invested this boy has been in the entire process. I think his parents have seen him as their golden boy (ctmom repeatedly talks about how good looking, smart, destined for great things, etc. he is). This is a heavy, heavy burden for a kid to bare, I should think. Does he know his mom is on here posting over a hundred threads looking for advice about college for him?</p>

<p>In her own op ctmom said that "in her heart" she doesn't think he is ready. A day or two later she changed her mind. I think she was right the first time. I think she does know the answer in her own heart and she should follow her instincts. Yes, it's embarrassing to have to answer nosy neighbor's questions about college plans. But who cares? What is important is the mental and physical health of her son.</p>

<p>The boy is not BEHAVING as if he is ready to leave home - he is sending out signals that he needs help. How much more can he spell it out? Perhaps he can work and take some courses at a nearby school. Sending him to college before he is ready is a recipe for disaster. Either he has an addictive personality or he doesn't, but his own mother seems to think he does. In that case sending him away to college is playing Russian roulette.</p>

<p>I hope the op doesn't feel like people are piling on, or, again, offended in any way. I don't intend to do so. The op asked for advice, and perhaps got more than she bargained for! :)</p>

<p>I tried to PM you, but your box is full! Evidently, others had the same idea.</p>

<p>Listen to Northstarmom. In fact, read back thru her previous posts. Sounds
like she has gotten her wisdom from her own life experiences, along with using her naturally logical mind. </p>

<p>AND DO NOT LET YOUR HUBBY UNDERMINE YOU. </p>

<p>Stand up to your husband and tell him that you have all tried his way to this point, and look where it got you, so now you are trying a NEW WAY. Tell him to stay out of it, please. Your hubby sounds like a 'feeler' who just doesn't want to lead, and your house needs a leader right now. Otherwise, your son will never get it together.</p>

<p>Best wishes!</p>

<p>just another thought. Son has ADHD and a craving for video games, but he is going to college anyway. To some extent, we are crossing our fingers, but the kicker is HEALTH INSURANCE. Depending on your or your spouse's employer, it runs out at 19, 21, 22, or 23. Then you buy the college's insurance or a COBRA</p>

<p>Our daughter's insurance is running out in April when she turns 22, and her college's insurance costs 1600 for the whole year. Gotta use a COBRA. One friend says her daughter's health insurance at NYU Med School is 3000 dollars a year, which is an unbelievable ripoff because if you weren't healthy, you'd never get through the program. So no gap years until there's universal coverage.</p>

<p>"I thought I made it clear.....but let me say again, HE DOES WANT TO GO TO COLLEGE VERY MUCH. He totally recognizes his chances and opportunities and doesn't want to blow it down the drain. He wants to go into business and international relations (what he is going to scool for) and is very much wanting to still pursue that path."</p>

<p>For what it's worth, here's my story.</p>

<p>Older S, who is brilliant, and ADHD, and was an academic underperformer (SATs 98th percentile, unweighted gpa about 2.9 in a rigorous program that he chose, but didn't bother to study for) said he wanted to go to college. So -- since he also was disorganized, I did the work of finding colleges that matched his interests, and then standing over him to make sure that he got college and scholarship applications in on time so that he could achieve his dreams.</p>

<p>Once he got into a college, which occurred Oct. of his senior year, he basically checked out of school. For instance, he got a D first quarter in AP English (had an SAT CR 99th percentile), and had some other low grades. He didn't bother to go to the teacher conference that his dad and I went to because S claimed he didn't realize that his own presence was expected.</p>

<p>By second semester, my H and I warned S that we would no longer hold his nose to the grindstone. If he didn't graduate from h.s., it would be his problem. He managed to graduate and get grades that allowed him to keep his admission and scholarship.</p>

<p>Went off to college -- and first semester got a 0.46 (!!!!) gpa. S said he wished to remain in colllege, indeed he said that he loved college, but had had problems with disorganization. H flew to the college to meet -- with S's approval -- with S and his advisor, who lined S up with a workshop in organizational skills, and hand picked courses for S for second semester. S had scores and ECs that made him among the top freshmen in his class. He had skipped a year, so the college thought that with the extra help of his advisor, and organizational help, S would get on track. They even allowed him to keep his scholarship.</p>

<p>S then flunked every course second semester. He loved college: partying in college, doing ECs in college, enjoying the college town, and having his college win the national championship in the sport he's the biggest fan of. He, however, had no interest in college academics. </p>

<p>S -- had exceptional skills in writing -- and spent the summer working out of our state in an excellent paid internship related to his writing. Then, he moved to the other side of the country, where he got a 6-month writing job (that paid the equivalent of $31 k a year). They didn't continue him on payroll, however, at the end of the 6 months possibly because they didn't want to seem to be encouraging S to stay out of college. But there may have been some other problems, too.</p>

<p>S then went to live with a childless, middle aged relative who lived 3,000 miles from our home in a state that S liked. The relative did not follow H and my advice to have S pay rent, so S got used to living a cushy life without working, though he claimed to be looking for work. He spent his ample free time organizing a rock band.</p>

<p>About a year later, I accidentally found S's blog and learned that S had started partying heavily in college (S had never partied before. Instead, he had spent his free time working in a field that he enjoyed and was literally a prodigy in. He hadn't even gone to things like prom.) He had continued his partying life while living with the relative, who was very naive and also was bamboozled by S into thinking that he was just a sad guy because he had been neglected by mean parents. </p>

<p>Long story short: It took her a couple of years to wake-up. Meanwhile, S stopped talking to H, his brother and me. I was under such stress that I ended up in the hospital with chest pains, and was diagnosed as being severely depressed. </p>

<p>It wasn't until the relative retired and moved away that S got his act together enough to work a steady job, gt his own apartment, and apparently stop the partying life. A couple of months ago, H, younger S and I traveled to see older S for the first time in 4 years. While older S hasn't returned to college, he does seem to be living a stable life, and is acting kindly toward us again.</p>

<p>The lessons we learned by raising older S helped us with younger S, another smart kid who was an academic underperformer. After H and I took him to visit various colleges, we told him that applying to colleges would be his responsibility. We'd pay for the fees, but we wouldn't structure his time so he got applications in.</p>

<p>This S also said he wanted to go to college, but somehow didn't get around to applying although he spent hours and hours staring at his computer doing what he called working on applications. </p>

<p>After the deadlines for the colleges that he was interested in passed, S -- who had done extensive volunteer work, something that he enjoyed -- managed to get an Americorps position created for him.</p>

<p>He -- SATs 98th percentile -- also just barely managed to graduate from h.s. and his grades fell big time second semester. H and I had warned him that if his grades crashed senior year, we would not pay for his first year of college nor would we pay for his college apps.</p>

<p>He did a gap year living at home (We made him pay a reasonable rent and follow family rules that we felt were appropriate for an adult), and being an Americorps volunteer. He could have lived away from home, but after seeing how much apartments cost, decided to save his Americorps stipend toward college. </p>

<p>With no structure from parents, he applied to two colleges, and chose the one that was a private college that gave him some merit aid, but still, he had to take out hefty loans. His first semester average was a 3.66. His second semester average was a little lower, but he also was working 10 hours a week, an active in several productive organizations, including having been chosen to be on the board of a campus wide one. </p>

<p>Although both of his roommates were partiers, S didn't get into that life. He made academically-involved friends, and had a nice social life with people serious about their studies.</p>

<p>H and I will contribute to his education next year, and as long as he maintains decent grades.</p>

<p>S has a summer job that he found himself. As part of it, he (at age 20) had the sole responsibility for organizing a seven-day summer leadership camp for middle and high school students. The camp is occurring now, and is going well.</p>

<p>So... that's my story. I hope my hard earned lessons keep others from enduring the heartache that I had with older S. If I had it to do over, I would not have done all of the work of organizing that S so he got his college apps in. After he had such a dismal first semester at college, H would not have flown up to help him stay in school. Instead, we would have sent S a ticket to return home because it would have been crystal clear that he was not ready to handle the academic side of college, which is the main reason to go to college.</p>

<p>I'd just note that there is no such thing as an "addictive personality" -- or at least there is absolutely no scientific evidence to support any such thing. See, for example, </p>

<p>Addiction Science Research and Education Center, Univ. of Texas, (" An addictive personality is presumably something that can be seen in young people that helps predict whether they will become “addicted” later in life. Scientists have not been able to find such a personality")
Addiction</a> Science Research and Education Center: Drug Myths</p>

<p>Two myths of addiction: the addictive personality and the issue of free choice (Research Journal Article) ("It is concluded that there is no evidence for the existence of a personality type that is prone to addiction")
Wiley</a> InterScience :: Session Cookies</p>

<p>The addictive personality: A myth (Research Journal Article) ("Recent prospective data ... leads to the conclusion that the addictive personality is a myth. ") The</a> addictive personality: A myth - Drug and Alcohol Review</p>

<p>This is one of these pop psychology labels that simply has no grounding in fact, especially when used cross-modally --that is, to extend an 'addiction" to gaming to a substance abuse. You can't predict one based on the other.</p>

<p>Maybe there is not an "addictive personality" per se (I'm not a psychiatrist),but there are addictive <em>behaviors.</em> There is a boy here whose mom has been in agony over his online gaming use for months and months. Whether one wants to call gaming an addiction or not seems to be an individual choice, but if you google internet or gaming addiction, you'll find dozens and dozens of articles about how this "addiction" can ruin lives.</p>

<p>We don't know a lot about this boy's drug use, but ctmom has dropped hints. She seems to blame it on his friends (his "friends" have been "banned" from the house). He hasn't used it in two weeks (as if that is an accomplishment of some sort). "Everyone here uses it." Whether or not there is an official "addictive personality" seems besides the point to me. </p>

<p>The point is that this boy is attempting to <em>escape</em> from reality through either gaming or pot (both mood altering experiences). I personally don't see one iota of evidence in this boy's behavior so far that points to the idea that he will suddenly stop these behaviors once he steps foot on campus and is out from under his mother's thumb. As blossom pointed out, the campus environment is going to be more than willing to help him find new and even better ways to check out.</p>

<p>I just want to cycle back to the depression comments people have made-- being bored with things, as you say your son seems to be, is a classic sign of depression. And a truly depressed kid is not going to have an easy time doing the things we're all hopeful about, like "snapping out of it," getting out of a rut, or waking up the next day to start doing things that will make his parents proud. </p>

<p>It might be that if you have him evaluated for depression, and got him help with that, a lot of these other things will better fall into place.</p>

<p>Being so bored as to be unable to accomplish much also can reflect substance abuse and addiction. No matter how caring and involved parents are, it is extremely difficult for parents to know the extent of their offspring's drug and alcohol use. I've known addiction counselors who themselves were recovering addicts/alcoholics who didn't realize that their kids were using drugs/alcohol.</p>

<p>It is amazing how creative people can be in hiding and lying about their drug and alcohol use.</p>